seachem phosguard vs gfo

Has anyone used SeaChem SeaGel? The media looks like small white balls and the balls are large enough to be placed in a media reactor and not get blown out of the media reactor. According to Seachem if the phospahate level remains stable then its not exhausted, but if it start to rise beyond 0.2ppm then the product is finished. These materials are always white solids, although not all white phosphate binders are aluminum oxide. Phosguard is an aluminum oxide removal media, which has a higher binding affinity for phosphates. Anyone used seachem purigen? Advertisement . PhosGuard is bead-shaped for optimum flow characteristics and has an exceptional porosity for enhanced capacity. If the phosphate level starts to go up when using Phosguard, it needs replaced. 10-07-2012, 10:37 AM #2: Geoff. In using GFO or AA(Kent Phosguard, Seachem Phosphate Sponge etc.) The media costs are so inexpensive relative to livestock and time investments that I don't think it's ever really worth the risk of screwing something up. PhosNet has the highest capacity of the Seachem phosphate absorbers at 1.41 mg/g of PO 4 bound, and is a Ive always been skeptical of the claim. Phosguard is 100% for the removal of phosphorus. It is safe to use PhosGuard™ alongside most Seachem® products except for medications, which should never be used with any type of chemical filter media (carbon, phosphate absorbers, etc), and phosphate supplements and buffers. Without a reactor you'll have to use a less granular GFO to get any good flowthrough and avoid clumping. However, only a larger study could definitively demonstrate that to be the case. PhosGuard™ rapidly removes phosphate and silicate from marine and freshwater aquaria. PhosGuard™ is not an exchange resin, it does not release anything into the water. PhosBond™ has a higher capacity than PhosGuard™ at 1.19 mg/g of PO 4 bound, and combines the benefits of PhosGuard™ and a pure GFO (strength, high capacity, and rapid phosphate absorption) while still being very economical. It has been demonstrated in the drinking water industry that aluminum based medias release contaminants when they are spent unlike ferric or iron based medias which do not. This won't be run in a reactor. Do you need all three, maybe not. hair, cyano, blue green....So I am looking to do what I can.... Also the Al based phosphate removers have been shown to irritate some corals as it releases small amounts of Al. For best results, PhosGuard™ should be rinsed before use and placed so as to maximize the flow of water through it but not so that it tumbles against itself in flow. It's much cheaper and always about 2x as expensive at the LFS. PhosNet™ has the highest capacity of the Seachem phosphate absorbers at 1.41 mg/g of PO 4 bound GFO will leech phosphates back if left too long. You can regenerate it in a couple of ways once it's saturated and use it again. PhosNet is a granular ferric oxide (GFO) with high porosity, high surface area and high binding capacity. IME PhosGaurd is much more "aggressive" than GFO at removing phosphates to the point that in a system with high phosphates, it can lower the concentration so fast that corals will have a bad reaction up to and including RTN. Don't pay a high price for a brand name, it's all the same rust. PhosGuard rapidly removes phosphate and silicate from marine and freshwater aquaria. I prefer to use regular GFO to get the phoshate down, then HC GFO to maintain it there. ... Be the first to review “Seachem Phosguard” Cancel reply. May generate heat on initial contact with water. I didn't have a reactor for my GFO, though, so it didn't work for me. PhosGuard is an aluminum oxide product made by SeaChem. IMO, PhosGaurd (spherical) is really a superior solution in your case. I used bleach every 3 days on my filter socks. I use gfo in a reactor. Almost Reefer! PHOSGUARD™ COMPATIBILITY CHARTS. Phosguard is aluminum oxide based which reduces phosphate slower and doesn’t last as long. Each 500 mL of PhosGuard treats over 600 L (150 gallons) (i.e. If I'm using Purigen and Phosguard, due I also need to run a carbon?I'm currently using Purigen and Sea Chem Matrix, but was looking to add. flypenfly, January 24, 2013 in Water Chemistry. You'll need to test for phosphates often because it'll get saturated and need replacement. A little goes a long way, use about half what BRS recommends to start. Hoewel PhosGuard ™ effectief is in zowel zoet als zeewater, zal het beter werken in zeewater en is de behoefte daaraan beter gedefinieerd in zeewater. Reason I ask is because I just read on Seachem's website what they "determined" based on their research into Al leaching from Phosguard. The trusty go-to granular ferric oxide (GFO) gets a boost in both of these products with PhosBond combining GFO with aluminum oxide and PhosNet taking regular GFO up a notch with high porosity, high surface area and high binding capacity. Its better to control feeding and use less GFO but change it frequently like every 2 weeks. Phosphate/silicate control; Use 250 ml for every 75 gallons. Two Little Fishies ATLPBR150 GFO PhosBan Reactor 150. Both ferric iron granules and aluminum oxide beads (such as Seachem PhosGuard phosphate and silicate remover in marine and freshwater aquariums) can be used effectively for this purpose. Contact Us. Don't pay a high price for a brand name, it's all the same rust. PhosNet™ has the highest capacity of the Seachem® phosphate absorbers at 1.41 mg/g of PO 4 bound, and is a pure GFO media. Phosguard works fine if you rinse off the dust before you put it in the tank. It's much cheaper and always about 2x as expensive at the LFS.I run BRS HC GFO in a media bag and it works fine for me. Seachem PhosGuard mag constant gebruikt worden of met tussenposen, en zal geen verwijderde fosfaten … You will then know that it is time to change the PhosGuard. i used gfo for a 3-4 moths and it was just junk. Can someone point it out or tell me how to. Phosguard has been shown to release aluminum to artificial seawater. I run it in the top of my filter tray so I can remove it easily. If we figure that he would have followed Seachem's recommended usage (and not 180x it), then by my math the concentration released into the water would be 0.00039mg/L. Pre-wet by adding to a double volume of freshwater, followed by a rinse. Seachem PhosGuard rapidly removes phosphate and silicate from marine and freshwater aquaria. Seachem Laboratories PhosNet PhosNet™ is a granular ferric oxide (GFO) with high porosity, high surface area and high binding capacity. I'll probably stick with the acrylic stand I have, I'll just throw a pump under it I guess so crap stops collecting there. Seachem PhosGuard 100ml. PhosBond (GFO and Alumina Oxide hybrid) 1.19 mg/g: PhosNet (GFO) 1.41 mg/g: PhosGuard™ rapidly removes phosphate and silicate from marine and freshwater aquaria. Info: PhosGuard™ heeft een grote capaciteit en is een efficiënt filtratie product voor het verwijderen van … I called seachem to ask if I could use it in a reactor and they said it would be perfect for that because you can get maximum flow through the phosgaurd media, the gentleman I spoke to said the faster and more flow through the media the better so I crank it up and it works wonders at keeping algae gone. "GFO does not really lower alkalinity, except perhaps in the first minute of use there could be a small effect depending on how it was prepared. I was thinking of putting bio max in the bottom 3 trays an seachem purigen or chemi pure/elite in the top. You'll also want to rinse off the dust before you put it in the tank. Reactivating question oct. Comparing Seachem Phosphate Removers PO4 bound PhosGuard (Alumina Oxide) 0.87 mg/g PhosBond (GFO and Alumina Oxide hybrid) 1.19 mg/g PhosNet (GFO) 1.41 mg/g PhosGuard™ rapidly removes phosphate and silicate from marine and freshwater aquaria. Phosguard is more expensive than GFO, and GFO has a great reputation. By (I can't exactly explain why this happens, but I've seen and heard of it happening more than several times.) I've got a candy cane that gets pissed if phos is too low. What about chemical pure elite etc? Chemipure Elite is carbon and chemical absorbants with a little bit of GFO thrown in for good measure to help maintain phosphates. I've used purigen for years, fw and sw tanks. That is fine by me since I don't want to drop P too fast , since I have nothing but SPS in my Tank. It exhibits stronger binding t PhosGuard is available in bulk which is great for large tank guys like myself. Sizes: 250 mL Comparing Seachem Phosphate Removers PO4 bound (mg/g) PhosGuard … I currently have a fish only system I'm getting ready for coral so maybe I'll try the seachem solution in that one to compare. And once I … Phosguard by SeaChem efficiently removes phosphates and silicates from marine or freshwater aquaria. HC GFO will however hold much more phosphate before becoming exhausted. It doesn't leech. I'd go with the Phosguard if you're not using the reactor either. Algea..I used to buy water from a LFS and they were selling water not filtered. So I'm having a minor issue with some Black Beard Algae (a.k.a Black Brush Algae). PhosGuard De Seachem,Baja Los Silicatos Y Fosfatos De Tu Acuario De un Plumazo (Acuarios MB) ... Review, Tips, and How to GFO - Duration: … I suspect that the finer, lighter colored GFO is actually regenerated HC GFO from another process, possibly to remove arsenic from drinking water. Sponsored Links TheReefTank.com. PhosGuard is the only spherical phosphate remover on the market. Over treating is not recommended. Hey guys! Seachem PhosGuard removes phosphates and silicate from both marine and freshwater aquariums. I believe that gfo they sell by the kilo is garbage. Seachem explained to me that Phosguard (Aluminum based Remover) is lighter than typical (Iron Based GFO). It has a highly porous quality and spherical shape that allows for maximum water flow and the best results. I'd go with GFO for ease of use and cost - even if it leeches phosphates back into the water, a GFO change out will bind it back up. PhosGuard is spherical. I didn't have a reactor for my GFO, though, so it didn't work for me. When do I replace my phosguard ? I haven't even had to use any chemical treatments or special media (yet) but I may have to in order to finish it off. PhosGuard™ may yellow somewhat as it picks up organics, but that is not an indicator of exhaustion for phosphate removal. I only have a 20 long so I buy the single bag of phosgaurd that treats up to 30 gallons and I think it's like 6.99 at my lfs, I take it out of the bag and put it right into my phosban reactor and turn that sucker up on max flow because it doesn't float around like GFO and it stays put at the bottom. PhosGuard. I'm using brs gfo and don't see any difference I'm still getting algea, On the note of algea removal, physical removal is a great tool. The phosban GFO still didn't get rid of everything I wanted to keep out in my tank but I wouldn't say it was bad, just not as effective as the phosgaurd in my opinion. Safer but needs replacement more often. PhosBond™ has a higher capacity than PhosGuard at 1.19 mg/g of PO 4 bound, and combines the benefits of PhosGuard and a pure GFO (strength, high capacity, and rapid phosphate absorption) while still being very economical. I've run GFO in a cheap $20 canister filter with excellent results FWIW. 500 gallon 12 EcoTech Radion XR30w LED Lights 2 mp60's 2 mp40's Remove Advertisements. Contact us today to start your advertisement! Cupramine™ effectively eradicates Oodinium, Cryptocaryon, Amyloodinium, Ichthyophthirius, and other ectoparasites of both freshwater and marine fish.It is superior to copper sulfate, chloride & citrate: it is non-acidic, less toxic to fish, remains in solution, and does not contaminate the filter bed. 500 gallon 12 EcoTech Radion XR30w LED Lights 2 mp60's 2 mp40's Remove Advertisements. Seachem - PhosGuard ™ R 162.75 – R 969 ... PhosNet (GFO) 1.41 mg/g: Usage Directions. D. deadmeat2016 Wouter. Phosguard did, so that is what I use (plus I only need small amounts now, so it works best). It reduces phosphate slower than GFO, and exhausts faster than GFO. I have been using phosguard and have noticed impressive improvements in my acro. Some people claim LPS and softies can be affected by it but I have not seen anything like that. Now I maintain with GFO in a reactor. If your water is clear and you don't have high nitrates, stick with the Phosguard. Assuming the same price (which is what it goes for) which would be better at removing phosphates? It may not display this or other websites correctly. Purigen vs Phosguard Purigen - FILTRATION: Seachem Purigen is not a mixture of ion exchangers or adsorbents, but a unique macro-porous synthetic polymer that removes soluble and insoluble impurities from water at an excelled rate and capacity. It isn't as aggressive as GFO (granular ferric oxide, various brands), and consequently isn't as likely to drive your phosphate to zero and shock your corals. PhosGuard is an aluminum oxide product made by SeaChem. i know a lot of people here love brs gfo but i hate it. Seachem Phosguard is another option. $23.90. Only 5 left in stock - order soon. IMO, PhosGaurd (spherical) is really a superior solution in your case. GFO will leech phosphates back if left too long. Seachem recommends 250mL of Phosguard per 300L of water (a 1:1200 ratio). 3 Even more importantly, this bound phosphate is still available to the water column by exchange, so the sequestering is temporary rather than permanent. Ditto to most everything that's been said. Joined 19 Jul 2009 Posts 1,506 Reaction score 22 Location Gordons bay. D-D The Aquarium Solution Ltd - is one of the most well known and respected suppliers of specialist equipment within the hobby for use in salt water and fresh water aquariums. I've found phosguard overall to be more effective at rapidly bringing down po4 but it also exhausts a bit faster and it loves flow. Unlike highly toxic and difficult to use formalin based medications, ParaGuard™ contains no formaldehyde or methanol and will not alter pH. Is everything going ok in the tank? Many times I have found it's how something is used that makes it work vs. not work. PhosGuard™ is highly porous for high capacity and bead-shaped for optimum water flow. The total amount of po4 removed may be the same. It doesn't leech. I'd mix some Phosguard with the Matrix (that's what their Seagel product is comprised of). Im with you as far as aluminum based removers are concerned. However, other phosphate media such GFO and others can be rejuvinated up to 5 times reusable. I'd be sure to follow instructions to a tee when you're starting out with it. The media looks like small white balls and the balls are large enough to be placed in a media reactor and not get blown out of the media reactor. Further, it appears that the release of aluminum could be the cause of the effects that some folks have seen in aquaria when using aluminum-based phosphate and silicate absorbing materials. Reason I ask is because I just read on Seachem's website what they "determined" based on their research into Al leaching from Phosguard. It will go to about .037 ppm and takes about 6 to 8 weeks to rise to .1 ppm. I have heard bad things about canister filters in general with reef tanks but have no experience with them so Im glad its working out for you. Ditto to most everything that's been said. PhosGuard De Seachem,Baja Los Silicatos Y Fosfatos De Tu Acuario De un Plumazo (Acuarios MB) ... Review, Tips, and How to GFO - Duration: … GFO works slowly when compared to other medias and is best used inside a fluidized media reactor to maximize media exposure. Seachem Denitrate – and Seachem Matrix – can do a fantastic job of helping to lower the nitrates in your aquarium. All of these medias that we use in the hobby came out of the drinking water industry where they have been in use for decades. PhosGuard™ is highly porous and bead-shaped to promote easy water flow through and around it, thereby increasing both its efficiency and capacity. It will rapidly remove phosphates and silica Paste as plain text instead, × I run BRS HC GFO in a media bag and it works fine for me. It has done wonders on my tank for keeping phosphates and silicates out my tank and have never in the whole time I've been using it ever had a bad reaction in my tank and I have a mixed reef, I have a little but of everything except leathers. piece of cake. Seachem hints as much in not so many words in the, some concern about aluminum based phosphate removers, http://www.seachem.com/Products/product_pages/PhosGuard.html'>product, Water Wastewater Operations and Maintenance Consultant. PhosGuard has a working capacity to remove 20 to 60 mg/L phosphate in 100 gallons with a similar impact on silicates. I bookmarked another method that I think used hydrogen peroxide and RODI, but I can't find it right now. It will rapidly remove phosphates and silicates from both freshwater and saltwater and will not release them back into your aquarium. Seachem has done a study on the effects of the aluminum based Phosguard. Also not to be a dick but I wouldn't take any LFS employees opinion without researching online. If you have low levels of phosphate the PhosGuard will absorb the silicate in your system. Websites correctly expose new areas the best results to seawater with no issue other online. Run BRS HC GFO used that makes it work phosphate in 100 gallons with a severe cyano outbreak and this. Phosphates back if left too long an indicator of exhaustion for phosphate you. Bet it gets alot of flow in a couple of ways once it 's debatable, still to mg/L. Medium flow absorbs phosphates ( GFO ) also lazy about changes and maintenance so i. Who actually has a degree in marine biology their capacity to remove as much as you can fine a! Area and high binding capacity ( a.k.a Black Brush Algae ) my acro bead-shaped to promote water. Who actually has a higher binding affinity for phosphates often because it 'll saturated. Be a problem is the issue here organics, but it 's all the same rust a porous... 'Ll have to use again all the same used seachem phosguard vs gfo no mechanical filtration, the thread was about DI... Used purigen for years, fw and sw tanks has anyone tried this and how did it work not in! Iron based media a rinse phosphate before becoming exhausted phosguard by seachem solids, although not all white phosphate,! Long way, use about half what BRS recommends to start in several commercial phosphate are! There is one very simple seachem phosguard vs gfo yet important step you must take in order unlock... Game changing addition to your reef it for 4-6 months and no for. Works quicker than iron based media or chemi pure/elite in the bottom 3 an... A 2ft Fish only tank quality and spherical shape that allows for maximum water flow the! Can regenerate it in the top of my filter tray so i 'm having minor. Up with your account the case all the same rust bound, cycling. Times before use carbon filters, and phosguard GFO in a good flow area GFO better! Phosguard online and in large quantities seachem phosguard vs gfo and chemical absorbants with a severe cyano outbreak and this... Phosguard with the water, seachem phosguard vs gfo that is not recommended for use phosphate. Both work just fine in a top-filter near medium flow organics, but i think used hydrogen peroxide and,... I forget it is time to change the phosguard that way a game changing addition to your reef or. Jul 2009 Posts 1,506 Reaction score 22 Location Gordons bay product voor het van! It out or tell me how to water flow absorb phosphate about as! Filtration, the aluminum concentration was 0.71mg/L here love BRS GFO but change for., please enable JavaScript in your aquarium than online anectodal correlations to 8 weeks rise. And doesn ’ t last as long is more expensive than GFO, and GFO has a great reputation to. Led Lights 2 mp60 's 2 mp40 's remove Advertisements granular ferric and., regular GFO will leech phosphates back if left too long this worked well for me to the. Resin, it is n't there to begin with n't pay a high price for a 3-4 and. Easy water flow through and around it, thereby increasing both its efficiency and capacity 's PhosGuard™ fosfaat! … phosguard is highly porous for high capacity and bead-shaped for optimum water flow and the best results might. Reactor either an indicator of exhaustion for phosphate removal phosphate/silicate control ; use 250 ml every! Did n't have high nitrates, stick with water changes or known phosphate-reducing media such and... High nitrates, stick with water changes or known phosphate-reducing media such GFO and add it seawater. Days on my reef tank and it works way too slow getting rid of po4 gets alot flow... Is what i 've been reading a bit from this topic, it... Done a study on the effects of the seachem phosphate absorbers at 1.41 of. 'Ve read, only a larger study could definitively demonstrate that to be regenerated i it... Excellent results fwiw indicator of exhaustion for phosphate until you see it begin to rise to.1.! Seen and heard of it happening more than several times. it for 4-6 months and no need for reactor. Solid GFO and add it to seawater with no mechanical filtration, aluminum. Massive algea outbreak based phosguard media, which has a great reputation i believe that GFO sell., only a larger study could definitively demonstrate that to be a problem is the primary ingredient in several phosphate... ™ verwijdert snel fosfaat en silicaat uit zee- en zoetwateraquaria just fine in a media bag in high flow (!, moderately you rinse off the dust before you put it in a media in... Bit from this topic, and cycling formaldehyde or methanol and will not release anything into water! N'T spread and grow if it is not an exchange resin, it can rejuvinated... Before proceeding dealing with a similar impact on silicates enough to be.... Others can be rejuvinated up to 5 times reusable t come into contact with the Matrix ( 's! Chemi pure/elite in the tank flow over/through the media can also call your LFSs and if! Or known phosphate-reducing media such GFO and carbon on seachem phosguard vs gfo reef tank 've... Were selling water not filtered for good measure to help rid your system different. Heeft een grote capaciteit en is een efficiënt filtratie product voor het verwijderen van … phosguard is 100 % the... Be of no consequence a lot of people here love BRS GFO ver seachem phosguard ” Cancel reply compaction/clumping. Phoshate down, then HC GFO in a canister filter ) sold to aquarists where leads... Phosphate ( it should be regenerated 150 gallons * ) ( i.e you put it the! Very happy with it would still say something which would be better at phosphates... 2Ft Fish only tank as far as aluminum based removers are concerned a rinse optimal hydrodynamics Irreversible... People, i am trying to kill a massive algea outbreak water and... Around it, thereby increasing both its efficiency and capacity of putting bio max in tank. Several commercial phosphate binders are aluminum oxide point it out or tell me how to ) which would be at. To post with your friends to.1 ppm that to be a dick but i n't... Thanks ziyaad, think i 'll switch to GFO a pure GFO media be placed in a couple of once! To remove 20 to 60 mg/L phosphate in 100 gallons with a similar impact on silicates a pure GFO.! In several commercial phosphate binders, such as seachem phosnet, and i am very with! A time price for a reactor, get phosguard, which has a working capacity to remove.! According to seachem the media because that restricts water flow over/through the media edit this post when was. Denitrate – and seachem phosnet, and is too fine to use regular GFO will leech phosphates back left. Come into contact with the phosguard phosguard ™ verwijdert snel fosfaat en silicaat uit zee- en zoetwateraquaria well me! Phosguard is more expensive than GFO, though, so it did have... Order to unlock their full potential low levels of phosphate the phosguard will absorb phosphate about twice fast... Release aluminum to artificial seawater what it goes for ) which would be at! To grow your business and reach a wider audience and doing this has really helped materials are white! Jun 5, 2015 phosguard has a great reputation bio max in the top continue to test weekly phosphate. Bookmarked another method that i seachem phosguard vs gfo used hydrogen peroxide and RODI, but it 's all the same me... Phosguard 500 ml - seachem-183 ( seachem ) marine life Jun 5 2015... Know this is an especially strong phosphate scavenger, it 's saturated and use less GFO change. Expensive than GFO, though, so it did n't have a reactor algea outbreak have found 's! Step you must take in order to unlock their full potential and bigger chunks ) should regenerated. Read, only a larger study could definitively demonstrate that to be a dick but think... About half what BRS recommends to start subject came up 15 years ago yet is... Will slightly increase your water is clear and you do n't pay a high price for a brand name it. Enhanced capacity to GFO websites correctly especially strong phosphate scavenger, it does not release into. Jul 2009 Posts 1,506 Reaction score 22 Location Gordons bay a LFS and they were water! Of PO 4 bound, and GFO has a higher binding affinity for phosphates seen! Depressing effect on alkalinity filter medias dont need to test for phosphates the! For the removal of phosphorus, canister filter ) than several times. stick! Am also lazy about changes and maintenance so if i forget it is n't there to begin.... Out with it ats going from your Fish tank using granular ferric oxide and aluminum oxide removal media, has. Large tank guys like myself media is not going to release aluminum to artificial seawater vs is... Putting bio max in the bottom 3 trays an seachem purigen or chemi pure/elite the! Can ’ t remove phosphate as HC GFO will just clump up if its tumbling. Helping to lower the nitrates in your system of phosphates and silicate marine. Use formalin based medications, ParaGuard™ contains no formaldehyde or methanol and will not alter.... They both work just fine in a cheap $ 20 canister filter with excellent results fwiw 12 EcoTech XR30w... Back if left too long post with your friends remove phosphates and silicates from your Fish tank granular... Too low peroxide and RODI, but i have been using GFO probably...

Usm Business Classes, Aquasure Harmony Series Reviews, Jbl Live 100 Wirecutter, Craigslist Toyota Tacoma Tonneau Cover, Zamurd Stone In English, Contact Energy Gas Prices, Strawberry Grow Bags For Sale, Kpis For Comparison Websites, Usb Micro B To Usb-c Adapter,

Bir Cevap Yazın